
If your child is in Key Stage 2, you have probably heard the words arithmetic and reasoning at a parents' evening, on a school report or in the run-up to SATs. Teachers use them all the time. Parents are rarely told what they actually mean, or why the difference matters so much for their child.
I'm Ross, a UK-qualified primary teacher with over ten years in the classroom. In this guide I'll explain the two halves of primary maths in plain English, show you what each looks like in a real question, and explain why I always fix arithmetic first when a child is struggling.
Quick answer: Arithmetic is the calculation part of maths: using written and mental methods such as column subtraction, short multiplication and short division to get an exact answer. Reasoning is applying those skills to word problems, puzzles and explanations, where your child has to decide what to do. Reasoning depends on arithmetic. If a child can't calculate reliably, they will struggle with reasoning however clever they are, so secure arithmetic comes first.
In this guide
What is arithmetic?
Arithmetic is the doing part of maths. It is the set of methods your child uses to add, subtract, multiply and divide, with whole numbers, decimals and fractions. When you picture the maths you did at school, a page of sums set out in columns, you are picturing arithmetic.
In primary school, arithmetic includes:
- Number facts such as number bonds and times tables, which children recall rather than work out.
- Mental methods such as partitioning and the strategies in my mental maths guide.
- Formal written methods: column addition and subtraction, short and long multiplication, and short division.
- Calculating with fractions, decimals and percentages, and using the order of operations.
An arithmetic question tells your child exactly what to do. 5,032 − 1,748 is a subtraction. There is no decision to make, only a method to carry out accurately.
What is reasoning?
Reasoning is using maths to solve a problem when the question doesn't tell you which calculation to do. Your child has to read the situation, work out what is being asked, choose the operations, carry them out and often explain their thinking.
Reasoning questions include word problems, missing number puzzles, "explain how you know" questions, spotting a mistake in someone else's working, and problems with more than one step. Schools also use the term problem solving for much of this. In practice the two are taught together.
The same maths, two ways
The easiest way to see the difference is to put an arithmetic question next to a reasoning question that uses exactly the same calculation.
| Arithmetic question | Reasoning question using the same skill |
|---|---|
| 342 × 6 | A school buys 6 boxes of pencils. Each box has 342 pencils. How many pencils does it buy? |
| 1,000 − 365 | Amira has saved £10. She buys a book for £3.65. How much money does she have left? |
| 744 ÷ 8 | 744 children go on a trip. Each minibus holds 8 children. How many minibuses are needed? |
| 3/4 of 48 | There are 48 sweets in a jar. Sam eats a quarter of them. How many are left? |
Look at the right-hand column. Every one of those questions needs an arithmetic method to finish it. If your child gets the method wrong, the reasoning question is wrong too, even if they understood the problem perfectly. The minibus question has a sting in the tail as well: 744 ÷ 8 is exactly 93, but if the answer had a remainder, the child would need to round up. Understanding what remainders mean is where arithmetic and reasoning meet.
How SATs test each one
The Year 6 maths SATs split the two halves very clearly. Paper 1 is arithmetic: 36 questions, 40 marks, 30 minutes, with no words at all, just calculations. Papers 2 and 3 are reasoning: 40 minutes each, 35 marks each, mostly word problems and puzzles.
So arithmetic is worth 40 of the 110 marks on its own, and it is needed for most of the other 70 as well. You can read more in my guides to the SATs arithmetic paper and the SATs reasoning papers.
▶ Video: the one skill schools skip, and why I teach arithmetic first. Watch on YouTube
Why arithmetic comes first
Schools are under pressure to move children on to reasoning quickly, because that's where the deeper thinking is, and that's what a lot of the curriculum and tests reward. That's a good aim. The problem is what happens when a child is moved on before their methods are secure.
Imagine a child who still forgets to exchange in column subtraction. Give them a two-step word problem and they might choose exactly the right operations, set it out beautifully, and still get it wrong because of one slip in the subtraction. To them, and often to their teacher, it looks like they "can't do word problems". In fact the reasoning was fine. The arithmetic let them down.
Over time, that child learns that maths is something they get wrong. That's where a lot of maths anxiety starts. When we go back and make the methods reliable, the same child suddenly finds word problems far less frightening, because they trust the calculation once they've decided what to do.
This is the idea behind my whole approach. I break primary arithmetic into 15 core skills, the written and mental methods every child needs by the end of Year 6.
Get those secure, and reasoning becomes something your child can actually enjoy. My free parent guide lists all 15 and shows you how to check which ones your child already has.
Get the free 15 Core Skills guideSigns the problem is arithmetic, not reasoning
It's easy to assume a child who struggles with word problems needs more word problems. Often they don't. Here are the signs the real gap is arithmetic:
- They understand what a question is asking, and can tell you which operation to use, but the final answer is wrong.
- Their mistakes are small and repeated: a missed exchange, a times table slip, columns not lined up.
- They avoid written methods and try to do everything in their head, or count on their fingers for large numbers.
- They do noticeably better when you let them use a calculator.
- Their arithmetic test scores are low, not just their reasoning scores.
If that sounds like your child, the quickest win is to find the specific method that's breaking down and fix that one thing. My guide to telling whether your child is behind can help you narrow it down.
How to help at home
You don't need to be good at maths yourself to help with this. You need short, regular practice on the right thing.
- Start with arithmetic. Ten minutes a few times a week on one written method will do more than an hour of mixed worksheets.
- Ask for the working, not just the answer. Mistakes in arithmetic are almost always visible in the working, so you can spot exactly where it went wrong.
- Use Watch, Copy, Practise. Watch a method being modelled, copy one example step by step, then practise a few alone. This is how I teach every method in class.
- Then add one word problem. Once a method is secure, give your child one real-life question that uses it, like the examples in the table above. Ask them to tell you which calculation they'll do before they start.
- Celebrate accuracy. Three correct answers are worth more than ten rushed ones. Confidence comes from getting it right.
If you'd rather have every method taught for you, step by step on video, my course Arithmetic Mastery 2.0 takes your child through all 15 core skills in short lessons they can pause and rewatch. It's currently £49 for the full course.
Want your child taught every method, step by step? Arithmetic Mastery 2.0 covers all 15 core arithmetic skills in short video lessons with practice sheets.
Your child watches a method, copies it and practises it, at their own pace, from home. Full course for £49.
See Arithmetic Mastery 2.0Frequently asked questions
What is the difference between arithmetic and reasoning in maths?
Arithmetic is carrying out calculations, using methods such as column subtraction or short division, when the question tells you exactly what to do. Reasoning is applying those methods to word problems and puzzles where your child has to decide what to do and sometimes explain why.
Is arithmetic or reasoning more important?
Both matter, but arithmetic comes first. Almost every reasoning question needs an arithmetic method to finish it, so a child with weak arithmetic will lose marks in reasoning too, even when they understand the problem.
How much of the Year 6 SATs is arithmetic?
Paper 1, the arithmetic paper, is worth 40 of the 110 marks. Papers 2 and 3 are reasoning papers worth 35 marks each, but most of those questions also rely on arithmetic methods.
My child is good at mental maths but bad at word problems. Why?
Mental maths is great for small numbers, but reasoning questions often use larger numbers or several steps where mental methods break down. Check that your child has reliable written methods to fall back on, and ask them to say which operation a question needs before they calculate.
Can I teach arithmetic at home if I struggled with maths?
Yes. Arithmetic is a set of clear, repeatable methods. If you learn one method alongside your child, using a worked example or a short video, you can check their working step by step without needing to be a maths expert.
Find out which of the 15 core skills your child is missing
My free parent guide lists the 15 arithmetic skills every child needs by the end of primary school, in the order they're taught.
Use it to spot the exact method that's holding your child back, then fix that first.
Get the free guideKeep going
Sources and further reading
- National curriculum in England: mathematics programmes of study (Department for Education)
- Key stage 2 mathematics test framework (Standards and Testing Agency)

